Will Philippe Saint Andre get France to be consistent? How
will Wales cope with injuries? Will Ireland carry their provincial form into
the tournament? Will Scotland finally start scoring tries? Can Italy avoid the
wooden spoon?
These are the questions for the first post-World Cup 6
Nations, which hopefully will go some way to being answered below.
England (9/2 Stan James)
Defending champions, although at a giant crossroads
following an abysmal World Cup quarter final defeat to France. To say that much
water has passed through the bridge since is an understatement. Out came the
revelations, out went Martin Johnson, and out went several of the “elite”
players that performed so poorly during the World Cup debacle, with the likes
of Lewis’s Deacon and Moody, Nick Easter, Mark Cueto & Louis Deacon, with
the living legend Johnny Wilkinson retired from the International game.
In came Stuart Lancaster, and masses and masses of new
faces, headed by Saracen’s inside centre Owen Farrell, who has risen steadily
throughought the last 12 months to a Premiership final win and Heineken Cup
Quarter finals. His starting at inside centre is surely going to be a big help,
while his goalkicking is a massive reassurance.
The problem as far as they’re concerned from a tournament
perspective is transition. Saracens pair Farrell and Barritt will become
England's first uncapped centre pairing since 2002 while Phil Dowson makes his
debut at 8 in the cauldron that is Murrayfield, while the most experienced
player (Charlie Hodgson) last played at this level 4 years ago and has just 46
caps.
The likes of new Captain Chris Robshaw has been exceptional
for Harlequins this year, although he’s just one of many that must prove
themselves in the cauldron of test rugby, and they would be much more appealing
without injuries to key personnel in Toby Flood, Courtney Lawes, Manu Tuilagi
and Tom Wood. A win against Scotland at Murrayfield would do wonders for the
new regime, but tough tasks against Wales and Ireland are arriving at Twickenham,
while a trip to Paris could be fearful.
France (13/8 Hills)
The great enigma of Test Rugby but not without a huge deal
of class, as shown by their wins in 2002, 2004, 2006, 2010, and their second
place last year despite an aberrational defeat by Italy. The best European side
at the World Cup despite a practical player mutiny against madman and constant
tinkerman Marc Liveremont, despite losing twice in the Pool stages and holding
on by the skin of their teeth against Wales, who some will argue where unfairly
deprived of Sam Warburton.
What was most impressive about France at the World Cup was
the solidity of the team in the latter stages after conceding 96 points in the
Pool Stage. Despite being thoroughly outplayed for long periods, they kept Wales
and New Zealand to single figures in the semi final and final, while you
couldn’t fail to be impressed by how deeply impressive they were in the first
half against England before holding out for a 12-19 win.
World Cups usually aren’t a good guide to 6 Nations performances
but the crucial ingredient here is the potential for them to improve on their
New Zealand performance. New coach Phillipe Saint Andre, a well-respected coach
who has 11 years at Gloucester and Sale, knows exactly what he wants from the
squad and having a united France – and we all know what France can do when at
their best – will prove a huge help to the tougher games.
As always, there’s plenty of good talent to pick from and a
new headline grabber could be Clermont centre Wesley Fofana, who has beaten the
most defenders and scored the most tries this season in the Top 14 for
Clermont, will get to play in midfield with Aulien Rougerie, while the rest of
the squad just oozes quality.
Having the mobile pairing of Louis Picamoles and Imanol
Hrarinordoquy at 8 should provide some sort of reassurance in their player
while a back three which includes Theirry Dusatoir and Julien Bonnaire should
provide a more than solid enough basis for success.
Having backs such as Parra, Yachvilli, Beauxis, Trunh Duc,
Mermoz, Malzieu. Medad and Poitrenaud just underlines their pace and it’s
really hard to get away for a squad of such obvious quality. A possible
negative is the lack of preparation but Italy at home first up should go a long
way to quashing that and allowing Saint Andre to find a healthy mix early on,
after which home advantage could make all he different.
Ireland (9/2 Skybet)
Third last year, when they destroyed England to prevent a
Grand Slam, before letting everything tick in time for the wild ride that was
the World Cup, where their powerpacked win against Australia set the template
for a renaissance which ended late on against Wales in Wellington.
12 points separated them on that day, but there’s good
reason to think the gap between them will close. Their chance for revenge takes
place on Sunday in their own backyard of Croke Park, with Wales not as strong
as they were for the World Cup clash.
It’s easy to forget just how poor they were before New
Zealand. Four test defeats in succession – 2 to favourites France – had left
many predicting failure for Kidney’s side but in the end they played their part
in one of the games of the tournament and many could forsee them going a lot
further.
They’re better fancied now thanks to more versatile play –
they destroyed Australia’s scrum through their tight 5 and then managed to
destroy Italy in the second half through sheer pace – while their provincial
success is stunning, Leinster, Munster and Ulster have all qualified for the
Heineken Cup quarter-finals for the first time, trashing prominent English
sides on two occasions.
A trip to Paris to take on a France side they haven’t beaten
in 12 matches is the major spanner in the works, but turn that result around
and anything is possible. There aren’t words strong enough to describe the loss
of Brian O’Driscoll, although he should be replaced easily by the likes of Cian
Heally and Sean O’Brien to smash up the scrum, while it’s to be hoped that the
club from Simon Zebo’s shown is continued into the tests.
Italy (200/1 general)
Fourth in 2007 but occupiers of the Wooden spoon since, last
year losing but to Scotland in points difference despite overturning France at
home. It’s a credit to them that they keep making steps – last year was the
first time that they’d ever beaten France, although every other side (Ireland
apart) had them roundly held before the end of the Championship.
The World Cup seemed to be a regression on that – they were
soundly beaten by Ireland and Australia in New Zealand – and the loss of Nick
Mallard is a massive blow. Yes, Jacques Burnel’s successes with Catalans in
2009 was based on the same forward dominated play that Italy specialise in, but
Nick Malett had overseen the previous progress and it remains to be seen just
how he fits in straight away given his quotes about adopting a more expansive
approach.
The four new faces - Aironi pair Alberto de Marchi and
Giovanbattista Venditti, the 21-year-old centre Luca Morisi and 18-year-old
winger Angelo Esposito –all lack experience at the highest level which will not
help in the grand scheme of things (away games against France first up, Ireland
and Wales).
Scotland (25/1 Betfred)
A side which was very unlucky not to make the Quarter finals
of the World Cup, but still one blighted by the main problem of tryscoring - they
have drawn a blank in 13 of Andy Robinson's 24 Tests. They scored 6 in last
year’s tournament although half of them came against a French side which was
home and hosed in Paris after outclassing them, and they could manage only four
at the World Cup too.
It’s becoming a serious problem for the Scots, with their
performances often outstripping the results. Argentina were outplayed for long
periods but needed just one to do the Scots over, while England’s later charge
thanks to Chris Ashton was enough to see them home at Eden Park.
Has Andy Robinson actually improved the side? Their
peformances would say yes, despite being 10th in the world still two
years after his appointment. Edinburgh’s Heineken Cup progression is a
promising sign at least for their home form, although the fixture list doesn’t
help their chances one bit and they’ll do well to have an impact.
Wales (10/3 Paddy Power)
The side that left everyone with egg on their faces during
the World Cup after all but winning a group which included holders South Africa
along with powerhouses Samoa and Fiji – previously responsible for their Group
stage exit at the second last World Cup.
What saw them do that from finishing just a slowly fourth in
last year’s competition? Results would hint at the cryotherapy chambers that
Wales utilised before last year’s World Cup, which turned them into one of the
fittest sides at the tournament based on stats; They scored 21 of their 29
tries in New Zealand during the second half.
They can also feel unlucky not to have beaten France in the
semi-final having been deprived of the inform Sam Warburton for 60 minutes
following what many see as an unfair red card – is it just coincidence that
Alain Rolland isn’t reffing a Welsh game?
That level of performance will obviously see them being
mightily hard to beat once again, although injuries threaten their progress and
it’s unlikely that France will play as badly as they did during that World Cup.
That said, having them on home turf is likely to prove a massive help if the title’s
still up for grabs on the final day (nearly always been the case) and nobody is
going to enjoy having Wales up at Twickenham.
VERDICT: World Cup form isn’t often the most reliable guide
to a 6 Nations campaign but France are worthy favourites after surpassing all
of their own expectations to reach the World Cup Final, and a favourable set of
fixtures – the exception being Wales away – could see them to the title. An
excellent defence was the foundation of their World Cup progress to the last
eight and a solid head to head record against Ireland (just one of two
important games they get in Paris) should prove helpful to building momentum,
while starting with Italy at home gives the team an excellent opportunity to
get the ball rolling and also helps overcome the major problem of their short
preparation time, which sets them up perfectly for a blockbuster clash with
Ireland in Paris. Declan Kidney’s side were brushed aside by Wales at the last
World Cup but several injuries for Gatland’s men evens the balance and getting
the game back onto home turf could be crucial, as they’ve won 5 of the last 6
fixtures in the Emerald Isle. With that in mind, backing them to finish second
to France at 5/1 makes plenty of appeal to small stakes. This in no way dismisses
Wales, although the first game against Ireland could see them on the backfoot
if they lost and it might be worth taking a shorter price after the game about
either side. England are defending champions but they now have to travel to the
Stade De France while Murrayfield today is no given for them seeing as they’ve
lost the last two in Edinbrugh. The new squad is promising, although patience
may be needed during this period of possible transition. Scotland don’t seem to
score enough tries still, while Italy have been handed a terrible set of
fixtures.
Advice
6.5 pts France (6/4 general)
1 pt France – Ireland (5/1 general)